Jump to content

Controversies

From AmwayWiki

Amway has been the subject of government action, lawsuits and media criticism in several countries during its history. This page lists the main ones by decade, with links to more detailed pages where they exist.

Timeline

2020s

  • India: Enforcement Directorate money laundering case (2022 to present)

In April 2022 India's Enforcement Directorate (ED) attached assets of Amway India Enterprises worth about ₹757 crore, including land and a factory in Dindigul, Tamil Nadu, plant and machinery, vehicles and bank deposits, under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA). The ED alleged that Amway was running a multi-level marketing scam and that most of its products were priced far above comparable products of reputed manufacturers.[1]

On 20 November 2023 the ED filed a prosecution complaint against Amway India in the Metropolitan Sessions Judge cum Special Court (PMLA) in Hyderabad, which took cognisance the same day. The ED alleged that Amway generated ₹4,050.21 crore in proceeds of crime through cheating and that more than ₹2,859 crore was sent abroad as dividends, royalties and other payments. The case grew out of complaints registered by Telangana police from 2011. Amway India said the complaint related to an investigation dating back to 2011, that it had cooperated with the authorities, and that it would "vigorously defend itself".[2] As of November 2026 no trial outcome had been reported. See Amway India.

  • Japan: six-month partial suspension (2022 to 2023)

On 13 October 2022 Japan's Consumer Affairs Agency ordered Amway Japan (日本アムウェイ合同会社) to suspend part of its multi-level marketing business for six months, from 14 October 2022 to 13 April 2023, under the Act on Specified Commercial Transactions. The suspension covered soliciting, accepting applications and signing new contracts, and the company was told to set up measures to prevent a recurrence.[3] The agency found that distributors had recruited people through dating and social media apps without first disclosing the company's name or that the purpose was solicitation. Amway Japan said it would introduce reforms to make sure its distributors follow the law.[4]

  • The Atlantic essay (2025)

In January 2025 The Atlantic published "The 'Exciting Business Opportunity' That Ruined Our Lives", a personal essay by journalist Andrea Pitzer about her family's experience in the Amway business in the United States.[5]

2010s

  • India: arrests of Amway India's chief executive (2013 and 2014)

On 27 May 2013 Kerala Police arrested William S. Pinckney, managing director and CEO of Amway India, and directors Sanjay Malhotra and Anshu Budhraja under the Prize Chits and Money Circulation Schemes (Banning) Act, 1978, over a complaint registered in Wayanad in 2011.[6] On 26 May 2014 Andhra Pradesh police from Kurnool arrested Pinckney again at the company's headquarters in Gurgaon, over a complaint by an advocate under the same Act alleging money circulation.[7]

  • Canada: Rhodes v. Amway class action (2009 to 2013)

An Amway business owner brought a proposed class action in the Federal Court of Canada claiming that Amway's practices broke the Competition Act. The court stayed the class action because the registration agreement required arbitration, and on 14 February 2013 the Federal Court of Appeal upheld the stay, ruling that such claims could be decided by arbitration.[8] See Cheryl Rhodes and Kerry Murphy vs Compagnie Amway Canada and Amway Global.

2000s

  • California class action (2007 to 2010)

In 2010 Quixtar settled a class action filed in 2007 by three business owners who alleged that it operated an illegal pyramid scheme, that recruits were misled, and that compensation depended mainly on recruiting and on the sale of motivational "tools". Quixtar agreed to pay up to US$34 million in cash and US$21 million in products.[9] See Pokorny & Blenn vs Quixtar, Inc et al.

The UK Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform petitioned to wind up Amway (UK) Ltd in the public interest. In 2008 the High Court refused the petition after Amway introduced a new business model and gave undertakings, and on 29 January 2009 the Court of Appeal dismissed the government's appeal.[10]

  • TIF vs Quixtar
  • Dateline NBC
  • Internet Critics

1990s

  • China: ban on direct selling (1998)

In April 1998 the Chinese government banned all direct marketing with immediate effect, citing illegal pyramid schemes, fraud and the sale of fake and smuggled goods. The ban threatened Amway, which had recently invested US$100 million in a factory in Guangzhou and distribution outlets in China.[11] See Amway China.

  • Sidney Schwartz and "Amway: The Untold Story" (1996 to 1999)

In 1996 Sidney Schwartz started "Amway: The Untold Story", a website critical of Amway. It covered issues such as the sale of motivational "tools" by distributor organisations, as well as other subjects of Schwartz's criticism.

In the late 1990s, during Amway's lawsuit against Procter & Gamble, Amway named Schwartz as a defendant and issued subpoenas to other critics. In April 1999 a federal judge in Minnesota refused Amway's request for the hard drive of Ashley Wilkes, a University of Minnesota technician who ran another critical website and had been in contact with Schwartz. Wilkes described the subpoena as an attempt to pressure him into closing his site. Schwartz closed his own site, citing the financial and emotional strain of the litigation.[12] Copies of it were kept online by others, including Jim Lippard, who said Amway's lawyers pursued the mirror sites and offered him a waiver that he refused.[13] Some critics saw Amway's actions as an attempt to suppress free speech. For Amway's position, see Amway Statement on Free Speech, on the Internet, and on Sidney Schwartz and P&G.

  • Procter & Gamble lawsuit over Satanism rumours (1995 to 2007)

In 1995 Procter & Gamble sued Randy Haugen and other Amway distributors over voicemail messages, sent to thousands of people, that repeated an old rumour linking P&G's logo and profits to Satanism. Amway itself was dismissed from the case. After 12 years and several appeals, a federal jury in Salt Lake City awarded P&G US$19.25 million against four former Amway distributors in March 2007.[14]

In 1997 82 consumer and environmental groups in South Korea formed an Anti-Amway Committee, alleging that Amway's dishwashing detergent was misleadingly marketed as environmentally friendly and was priced two to three times higher than local products. Amway denied the claims and refused to make the public apology the groups demanded. The Wall Street Journal reported that Amway's Korean sales fell sharply during the campaign.[15]

1980s

  • Canadian customs case (1983)

Amway began selling in Canada in 1962. Canadian customs duty was based on the value of imported goods, and the dispute concerned the "transfer price" Amway used to value goods sent from the United States to its Canadian business.

In 1983 Amway Corporation and Amway of Canada pleaded guilty in the Supreme Court of Ontario to defrauding the Canadian government of customs duties between 1965 and 1982, and were fined C$25 million, then the largest fine in Canadian history. In return, criminal charges against co-founders Richard DeVos and Jay Van Andel and two other officials were dropped. The government also sought about C$148 million through civil claims.[16]

In a statement to the court, Amway said it had believed its transfer price was a fair value for duty purposes, but accepted that because it did not sell to outsiders at that price, the method did not comply with the Customs Act (Ragin v. Amway, 1983, Exhibit 2). The civil claims were later settled; the settlement has been reported as C$45 million in 1989. In 1996 a Canadian court ruled that Amway could not deduct the fine as a business expense for tax purposes.

  • Directly Speaking (1983)

In 1983 Rich DeVos recorded an audio tape titled Directly Speaking, distributed to Diamonds and above in the United States, partly in response to a 60 Minutes report on Amway. In it he set out ten rules for distributors. In summary:

  1. Respect the line of sponsorship and do not "cross-line" into other distributors' groups.
  2. Use only Amway-approved literature and figures when showing the plan, and make no unrealistic income claims.
  3. Support every sponsored distributor, whether or not they buy tapes. DeVos said it is "a sponsor's responsibility to train, motivate and supply their people".
  4. Keep tapes, books and rallies voluntary: "No strings, no pressure, and no force."
  5. Tell prospects that they are invited to a business opportunity meeting, and answer "yes" if asked whether it is Amway.
  6. Leave plan and product material to the company; distributors should not produce their own.
  7. Do not hide behind group names instead of saying the business is Amway.
  8. Treat everyone with respect and do not label people who choose to do less as "losers".
  9. Do not present the business as being only about money.
  10. Do not load up on inventory or push products onto others to win a pin or a trip.

The tape is often cited as an early acknowledgement by Amway's leadership of concerns about the "tools" business and about how some distributors recruited. A transcript and recording were published here.

1970s

1960s

1950s and before

Amway's founders began as distributors of Nutrilite products, and Amway grew out of disputes between Nutrilite's distributor organisation and the company that made the products.


A long-running debate concerns the "tools" business: the motivational books, recordings and events sold by distributor organisations, whether they are profitable for the people selling them, and how much of senior distributors' income comes from them. The issue was raised in Directly Speaking in 1983 and in later disputes such as the California class action and the UK government's case against Amway UK. See also Amway UK & ROI.

References

  1. ↑ Enforcement Directorate attaches Rs 757-crore assets of Amway India under PMLA. The Tribune, 19 April 2022. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  2. ↑ ED files prosecution complaint against Amway India under PMLA, alleges company made Rs 4,050 cr by cheating. Business Today, 21 November 2023. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  3. ↑ 連鎖販売業者に対する行政処分について (Administrative disposition against a multi-level marketing operator). Consumer Affairs Agency, Government of Japan (in Japanese), 14 October 2022. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  4. ↑ Amway Japan Ordered to Partially Suspend Operations for Six Months. Unseen Japan, 14 October 2022. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  5. ↑ The 'Exciting Business Opportunity' That Ruined Our Lives. The Atlantic, 30 January 2025. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  6. ↑ Amway India chief, 2 directors arrested. Business Standard, 28 May 2013. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  7. ↑ Amway India CEO arrested. Business Standard, 28 May 2014. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  8. ↑ No basis to conclude that claims could not be determined by arbitration. Law Times, 15 April 2013. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  9. ↑ Amway Subsidiary Settles Lawsuit. ConsumerAffairs, 4 November 2010. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  10. ↑ Secretary of State for Business, Enterprise & Regulatory Reform v Amway (UK) Ltd [2009 EWCA Civ 32]. The National Archives (UK), 29 January 2009. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  11. ↑ China bans direct marketing firms. Business Standard, 23 April 1998. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  12. ↑ U staff member retains hard drive in investigation. Minnesota Daily, 29 April 1999. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  13. ↑ Amway and the mirrors of "Amway: The Untold Story" (message from Jim Lippard). Politech mailing list, 10 March 2000. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  14. ↑ Procter & Gamble Wins Satanism Suit. CBS News, 20 March 2007. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  15. ↑ Amway Finds It's Washed Over in a South Korean Soap Drama. The Wall Street Journal (reproduced by Corporate Frauds Watch), 1997. Retrieved 2 November 2026.
  16. ↑ Amway Fined $25 Million in Canadian Fraud. Christianity Today, 16 December 1983. Retrieved 2 November 2026.