Jump to content

FTC vs Amway

From AmwayWiki

In the Matter of Amway Corporation, Inc., et al. (FTC Docket 9023, 93 F.T.C. 618) is the 1979 decision of the United States Federal Trade Commission (FTC) which found that the Amway Sales and Marketing Plan was not an illegal pyramid scheme, while ordering Amway to stop fixing resale prices and to stop making misleading earnings claims.[1]

Background

In March 1975 the FTC issued a complaint against Amway Corporation, the Amway Distributors Association, and Amway's founders Jay Van Andel and Richard DeVos, charging violations of Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act. The charges covered price fixing, restrictions on how distributors could sell, operating a pyramid scheme, and misrepresenting what distributors could earn. Hearings ran from May to October 1977. In an Initial Decision on June 23, 1978, the administrative law judge found that Amway had engaged in illegal resale price maintenance but rejected the other charges.[1]

At the time, Amway made more than 150 products, mostly cleaning and personal care products. It had sales of over $200 million in 1976 and about 360,000 independent distributors.[1]

Decision

The Commission's opinion was written by Commissioner Pitofsky, and the Final Order was issued on May 8, 1979.[1]

  • Price fixing: the Commission agreed that Amway and its distributors had fixed resale prices at both the wholesale and retail levels, in violation of Section 5.
  • Earnings claims: statements naming specific dollar amounts, such as the 1975 Career Manual's suggestion that a recruit could "develop an income of as much as $1,000 per month", were found to have the capacity to deceive potential distributors. General statements about opportunity and achieving one's dreams were treated as motivational "puffs" that few people would take literally.
  • Not a pyramid scheme: the Amway plan was found not to be an illegal pyramid scheme, because bonuses depended on sales to consumers and three rules deterred "inventory loading": the buy-back rule (unused products are bought back from distributors who want to leave), the 70 percent rule (a distributor must sell at least 70% of the products bought in a month to receive the Performance Bonus), and the ten-customer rule (each distributor must make retail sales to ten customers every month).
  • Other charges, including the challenged non-price distributor rules, were dismissed.

The order

Amway and the other respondents were ordered to stop fixing or stating the prices at which distributors sell, and to stop misrepresenting distributors' earnings. Any claim that distributors earn a stated amount above the average had to be accompanied by a clear disclosure of the average earnings of all distributors, or of the percentage of distributors who actually achieved the stated amount. Amway also had to send a copy of the order to all of its distributors within 30 days.[1]

Full decision

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 In the Matter of Amway Corporation, Inc., et al. Docket 9023. Final Order, Opinion, etc.. Federal Trade Commission, 8 May 1979. Retrieved 3 November 2026.